Korin and liberu-genealogy/php-gedcom¶
Generated by tools/liberu-comparison/compare.php on 2026-11-15 with PHP 8.5.12, liberu-genealogy/php-gedcom 4.2.0 and Korin bcc7ada.
Each corpus input is read and written back by each library; the output is read with Korin and its structures (tag path and value, xrefs and order ignored) are compared with the input's.
Notes:
- liberu documents support for GEDCOM 5.5.1 only; the 7.0 and UTF-16 cases are included for completeness.
- A structure under a record whose xref was not written back counts as lost: pointers to it no longer resolve.
- liberu writes a
Format: …line beforeHEAD; Korin reads it as an unparsable line and ignores it. - Performance: one run per file on the machine that generated the report, not a PHPBench measurement.
Summary¶
| Korin | liberu | |
|---|---|---|
| Read and written without an exception | 64 of 64 | 11 of 64 |
| Output identical to the input | 64 of 64 | 0 of 64 |
| All structures kept | 64 of 64 | 2 of 64 |
| Structures kept | 21337 of 21337 | 4 of 21337 |
| PHP warnings raised | 0 | 102 |
liberu exceptions¶
| Exception | Cases |
|---|---|
Exception: Unknown Gedcom\Record\Head\Char::version |
27 |
Exception: Unknown Gedcom\Record\Subm::subn |
24 |
Error: Call to undefined method Gedcom\Writer\Indi::convertEvent() |
1 |
Exception: Unknown Gedcom\Record\Obje::file |
1 |
Reading the benchmark files¶
Generated, fictional 5.5.1 files (benchmarks/BenchFile.php); full read, each in a separate process.
| File | Korin | liberu |
|---|---|---|
| 10 MB UTF-8 | 0.33 s, 66 MB | 0.5 s, 182 MB |
| 10 MB Windows-1251 | 0.51 s, 99 MB | 0.62 s, 224 MB |
| 50 MB UTF-8 | 1.77 s, 405 MB | 2.85 s, 938 MB |
Corpus cases¶
Structures kept; for liberu, the tag paths it lost (first five).
| Case | Version | Encoding | Korin | liberu | Lost by liberu |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ansel-diacritics-551 | 5.5.1 | ANSEL | 7/7, identical | exception | |
| conc-cont-at-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 7/7, identical | exception | |
| cyrillic-cp1251-ansi-551 | 5.5.1 | Windows-1251 | 13/13, identical | exception | |
| edit-long-note-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 6/6, identical | exception | |
| edit-surname-70 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 7/7, identical | 1/7 | INDI, INDI/NAME, INDI/NAME/GIVN, INDI/NAME/SURN, INDI/SEX |
| g7c-5-age-invalid | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 281/281, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-age-valid | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 125/125, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-atsign | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 23/23, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-char-ascii-1 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-char-ascii-2 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-char-utf16be-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-16BE | 5/5, identical | 0/5 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, HEAD/NOTE, SUBM, SUBM/NAME |
| g7c-5-char-utf16be-2 | 5.5.1 | UTF-16BE | 5/5, identical | 0/5 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, HEAD/NOTE, SUBM, SUBM/NAME |
| g7c-5-char-utf16le-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-16LE | 5/5, identical | 0/5 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, HEAD/NOTE, SUBM, SUBM/NAME |
| g7c-5-char-utf16le-2 | 5.5.1 | UTF-16LE | 5/5, identical | 0/5 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, HEAD/NOTE, SUBM, SUBM/NAME |
| g7c-5-char-utf8-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-char-utf8-2 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-char-utf8-3 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-date-all | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 8761/8761, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-date-dual-invalid | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 258/258, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-date-dual-valid | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 38/38, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-enum-ext | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 19/19, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-filename-1 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 24/24, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-lang-all | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 103/103, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-notes-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 19/19, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-obje-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 21/21, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-obsolete-1 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 13/13, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-pedi-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 10/10, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-rela-1 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 13/13, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-sour-1 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 41/41, identical | exception | |
| g7c-5-tiny-1 | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 1/1, identical | 1/1 | |
| g7c-5-xref-case | 5.5.1 | ASCII | 8/8, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-age-invalid | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 281/281, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-age-valid | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 137/137, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-atsign | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 23/23, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-ascii-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-ascii-2 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf16be-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf16be-2 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf16le-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf16le-2 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf8-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf8-2 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-char-utf8-3 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 5/5, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-date-all | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 10334/10334, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-date-dual-invalid | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 342/342, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-enum-ext | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 22/22, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-filename-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 23/23, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-lang-all | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 108/108, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-notes-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 19/19, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-obje-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 22/22, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-obsolete-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-pedi-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 10/10, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-rela-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 15/15, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-sour-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 47/47, identical | exception | |
| g7c-7-tiny-1 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 1/1, identical | 0/1 | HEAD |
| g7c-7-xref-case | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 8/8, identical | exception | |
| line-endings-mixed-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 7/7, identical | exception | |
| minimal-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 4/4, identical | exception | |
| minimal-70 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 1/1, identical | 1/1 | |
| no-final-newline-70 | 7.0 | UTF-8 | 3/3, identical | 1/3 | INDI, INDI/NAME |
| unknown-tags-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 16/16, identical | exception | |
| utf16be-bom-55 | 5.5 | UTF-16BE | 7/7, identical | 0/7 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, SUBM, SUBM/NAME, INDI |
| utf16le-bom-cyrillic-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-16LE | 7/7, identical | 0/7 | HEAD, HEAD/SUBM, SUBM, SUBM/NAME, INDI |
| xref-forward-void-551 | 5.5.1 | UTF-8 | 12/12, identical | exception |